Ever since I was a little kid, I've always wanted to know why things are as they are. I just like working backwards and seeing how something came to be, how, given the proper circumstances, how what had happened was not just likely, but inevitable, a natural consequence of its antecedents.
And the study of history would seem like a natural fit for that mindset, but I was never interested in history as a kid, or really, up until a couple years ago. Indeed, I dreaded it. History was always my worst subject. (Except for spelling. Part of the reason I worked to develop an expansive vocabulary was so that I could find single-syllabled synonyms for hard to spell words.)
And the reason, I think is that, grade school through college, I've never had a good history teacher. I've had plenty of good teachers covering all aspects of English, from lit to composition, and I grew up with a hunger for the subject, and maybe even a little bit of an aptitude. Same with science. My best friend's stepfather is a chemist, and he's one of those multidisciplinary mad genius types that knows everything about everything. So I grew up with a healthy respect for science in general. I never realized how much those early teachers shaped the person I would become. The science and the writing are a strong part of how I see myself.
But the same was never true of history. It was always rote memorization of names and dates, with no discussion of the wider context. It was about as engaging as those Old Testament lists of begats. We never looked at why anything happened. In the words of Milhouse Van Houten, "First it started to fall over. Then it fell over."
Also, I'm still annoyed that my history teacher in high school marked this wrong.
Q: Who was Barbarossa?
A: Willie Nelson's character in the film of the same name. Also, Holy Roman Emperor Frederick I.
A: Willie Nelson's character in the film of the same name. Also, Holy Roman Emperor Frederick I.
Come on, Mrs. Skoog! Which part of that is wrong?!
I was talking about the NPR radio show, This American Life, with my friend Greg one time. He had listened to an episode of which I had spoken highly, and he said that while he enjoyed it, it didn't strike him as particularly balanced. I said that I didn't think that it was their goal to present a balanced look at the topic, but rather to tell a story about it. So, while it was factual, different facts were given different emphasis in service of the narrative they had crafted. (And I do think they are pretty good about addressing rather than ignoring points that would undermine their thesis.)
And I find a similar sensibility at work in Sarah Vowell's work. She's not attempting to give a comprehensive overview, but rather, to make a point, to tell a story. And all the while through, she'll pepper it with digressions, and anecdotes and how she sees its relevance to events occurring in the world today, a technique I naturally find appealing, in that I employ it myself.
And that's the kind of history teacher I never had, the kind that showed me why I should care. . I went to a teeny-tiny grade school, but we had some really phenomenal teachers who worked wonders on a shoestring budget. Her school experience is going to be very different than mine was, but I hope Lily has that kind of teacher. Because a good teacher will change your life.




